Peer Review Policies
International Scientific and Innovative Research Publisher (ISIR Publisher) is committed to publishing high-quality scholarly papers with significant policy implications and academic contributions.
The decision on each manuscript follows a rigorous peer-review process consisting of three stages:
Stage 1: Initial Editorial Assessment
A distinguished member of the editorial board conducts an initial assessment of the manuscript to evaluate its overall quality, relevance, originality, and suitability for the journal, in accordance with the journal’s aims, scope, and submission guidelines.
Stage 2: Double-Anonymous Peer Review
The manuscript is evaluated by two anonymous peer reviewers who assess its scholarly quality, clarity of presentation, methodological soundness, and suitability for publication.
Stage 3: Final Evaluation
Following the initial assessment and peer reviews, the manuscript undergoes a final evaluation based on the following six key criteria:
-
Originality and significance of the research.
-
Value and relevance of the research question.
-
Identification and contribution to the research gap.
-
Quality of the conceptual framework and the appropriateness of the technical or methodological approach.
-
Quality of the results, discussion, and interpretation of findings.
-
Overall contribution to the field and quality of academic writing.
Editorial Decision
After the final reviewer’s comments have been received and evaluated, the editorial team makes a decision regarding the manuscript. The review and decision process is conducted as efficiently as possible, with a target timeframe of one to two weeks, depending on reviewer availability, the nature of the manuscript, and the completion of the required evaluation stages.




